Wednesday, January 03, 2007
Zapatista encounter in Oventik
Arriving in Oventik after an hour's ride into the highlands, we register and I go claim some floor space to stretch out a sleeping bag in the auditorium, where the organizers have thoughtfully spread a bed of pine needles over the dirt floor. There is a festive atmosphere, with food stands and a dozen or so makeshift eateries and tables with literature and posters and music and artisanry. Some 4,000 people will eventually crowd into the tiny space (not "hundreds," as the New York Times claimed in a typically inaccurate report), including Zapatista community members from the 5 autonomous regions as well as national and international supporters (the latter mainly Europeans, plus some Chicano activists from L.A.). Some pitch tents or sheets of plastic, while others fill every inch of floor space in the auditorium and school buildings. Everything is very well organized, with ski-masked details of Zapatistas attending to everything from food and water to garbage and latrines. A stage and chairs are set up on the basketball court and beyond, with a sound system, while smaller sessions are held in the indoor spaces.


After a brief opening ceremony with a welcome and the Mexican and Zapatista anthems, the first session is a plenary on autonomy. The format followed in each session provides for presentations by members of the Juntas de Buen Gobierno (Good Government Councils) from each of the 5 Caracoles, 20 minutes each; then a half hour of responses to questions submitted in writing; then two hours to hear anyone who signs up to speak for 5 minutes each. The next two days of sessions cover education, health, women's issues, commerce, communication & culture, and land & territory. On New Year's eve, Marcos makes a low-key appearance to read a long statement in Tzotzil, which Comandante Hortensia reads in Spanish afterwards, after which those who still had energy danced away the night to the sounds of two bands.
As with any meeting, a lot of the liveliest discussions occur informally among participants outside the organized sessions. I share sleeping quarters with a bunch of Mixe indigenous people from the mountains of Oaxaca state, grassroots activists who do alternative media and popular education work and are tied to the current APPO movement, the Popular Assembly of the Peoples of Oaxaca. They are typical of the diverse and impressive array of activists present, many young and most representing organizations that have sprouted up in the last ten years with no ties to traditional party politics. The format of the formal sessions is less an "encounter" or dialogue as billed than a kind of report from the Juntas on how they have been implementing the autonomy project in their respective regions in the two and a half years since that regional governing structure was created.
Still, it was useful to have that broad overview, since the governance is decentralized with a fair amount of variation between the five Caracoles, and for that reason it was probably just as interesting for the Zapatista participants as for the solidarity activists. Some of the Zapatista presenters struggled with Spanish and some read their presentations, while others spoke extemporaneously and eloquently. Because of the breadth of topics and lack of breakout sessions, it was hard to get into too much depth. Some of the compas who spoke gave rather simplified and rosy versions of reality--such as assertions that women participate fully and equally in community assemblies, or that all lands recovered from the wealthy landowners are worked collectively. But others were more specific and candid about problems and shortcomings, such as the economic constraints that lead some education promoters to abandon their duties, or that drive increasing migration in search of work elsewhere in Mexico or the U.S.; and the fact that the Zapatista judicial system in still piecemeal and lacking overall codification.
There was a certain amount of posturing and pontificating by some of the solidarity groups, but less so than at the beginning of the Other Campaign, now that there has been a kind of sorting out between those who talk and those who act. There was also a notable presence of clear-thinking and battle-tested groups from Atenco and Oaxaca, which helped remind everyone that in these increasingly repressive times we can ill afford to be frivolous or sectarian.
Liliana, the Argentine doctor, later pointed out the absence of some of the important South American movements, such as the Brazilian rural landless workers (MST) and the Bolivian indigenous movement. This reflects in part the Zapatistas' refusal to ally with any party or government, so that the MST's past support for Lula's PT party and the Bolivian movement's backing of the successful candidacy of indigenous President Evo Morales have led the Zapatistas to keep a wary distance. In fact, when the Zapatistas were invited to send a representative to Evo Morales' inauguration, instead of just politely declining they responded to the effect that they had no intention of strutting about on the international stage, seemingly a gratuitous slap at a president who was swept to power by a popular movement and had not yet proved to be a sellout.
For all its missteps, however, the Other Campaign may be starting to gel at the national level in the current context of widening repression and declining legitimacy of the political class. Back in San Cristóbal, the day after the encuentro, I attended a forum with speakers from the Frente de Pueblos en Defensa de la Tierra (People's Front in Defense of the Land) from Atenco, the Asamblea Popular de los Pueblos de Oaxaca, APPO (Popular Assembly of the Peoples of Oaxaca), and the Other Campaign, and it was a standing-room-only crowd.
Friday, December 29, 2006
returning to the scene of the crime
My flight from Mexico City to Tuxtla was delayed for four hours, allegedly for bad weather, though friends later told me that was the standard excuse for cancelling and combining flights that didn't fill. My bag arrived torn, and when I went to file a claim I was told the airline could send it out for repair, but I would be responsible for delivering and retrieving it to the airport an hour from San Cristóbal where I would be staying, so I gave up on the claim. Gerardo, the taxi driver that Bela had arranged to pick me up, was waiting patiently. He politely asked if I minded the blaring music in the cab, which I didn't as it was a nice marker of reentry to Mexico. He stopped for gas, a leisurely affair as he caught up on gossip with the station attendants. Then we came across a broken-down taxi on the winding road to San Cristóbal, so of course he had to stop to see if he could help a fellow cabbie get his car running. Our journey was slow but well blessed, as Gerardo crossed himself energetically at the beginning and end of the trip and at every bridge and church along the way.
Peter and María Elena had kindly offered to let me stay in their house while they were out of town, but I arrived too late at night to pick up the key, so Bela and Sangit put me up for the night. The next morning I picked up the key from Ernesto, who runs a small NGO that tracks the low-intensity war here and monitors human rights violations by the army and paramilitaries. He recently started a little cafe/restaurant operation that also rents space to some Zapatista artisanry cooperatives and other NGOs. I asked Ernesto if he knew of any trucks heading to the jungle, since I had brought down $1,200 in donations to buy school supplies for the Zapatista autonomous schools in the region where I've been working. He said as a matter of fact he might be taking a trip with a large van the next morning, stopping first at another Caracol (regional Zapatista center) but then to my destination.
So the scramble was on to assemble and pack the supplies in one day. I tried to reactivate my cell phone which didn't seem to be working, and was told I had to go to the Telcel customer service office across town. Once that was accomplished, I called Bela to tell her the good news about the possible transport, since she has been storing school supplies in her house and serving as a waystation and providing invaluable logistical support for the project. She offered to hire the trusty Gerardo and go to Tuxtla an hour away to buy the supplies, which was a huge help as I had an impossible number of things to do in the remaining hours, and I was rediscovering that everything takes four times as long to accomplish in Mexico. So I ran to a large stationery store to buy six big boxes of chalk, which I knew they didn't have at the discount supply store in Tuxtla, then dashed to a bank to stand in line for an hour to change money, then back to Bela's with the cash and list. Then I went off in search of empty cardboard boxes for the repacking, hitting up the egg ladies in the marketplace and several stores, then in search of a hardware store for packing tape, then to buy a few provisions for the trip.
While waiting for Bela and Gerardo to return, I went to see Don Andrés, the respected local historian who is a collaborator on the book project I'm co-editing with Bruno and Mariana, a compilation by researchers working in Zapatista territories. Andrés was in high spirits as usual, talking with characteristic animation and French gesticulation about the upcoming Encuentro. I gave him a copy of the final version of the book proposal, which he is going to present to his old friend who directs one of the larger social science publishing houses. We're all enthusiastic about this project, which we envision as more participatory than many academic endeavors. We've already had several meetings in San Cristóbal and Mexico City of chapter authors, and the proposal has been circulating in drafts among the authors until we were all happy with it. We are also committed to getting permission from the Zapatista elected authorities in the respective regions where we're working to write about their experiences with autonomy, and then returning to discuss our drafts with them--unlike so many academics who consider themselves uniquely "objective," and who treat the populations they study as mere objects of their intellectual curiosity. Most of our chapter authors also do direct solidarity work in the communities, as educators, doctors, psychologists, agroecologists, etc., which gives them experience and a different kind of insight into the problems and possibilities of the autonomy movement.
After the meeting with Andrés I track down Liliana, an Argentine "movement doctor" who has just returned to Chiapas for another stint developing training programs for Zapatista health promoters. She always has an interesting grassroots perspective on political issues, and we exchange impressions of the current conjuncture in Mexican politics. A recent cover story in the left-leaning weekly Proceso discusses the strong ties that the incoming Calderón administration is building with the Army, a quasi-independent actor and power center in Mexican politics (as are the Church, the narcos, big business, the U.S., and the PRI's continuing network of local patronage/powerbrokers, in addition to the untouchable office of the Presidency itself). Calderón moved quickly to grant the military a large budget increase including hefty pay raises for the troops, apparently attempting to consolidate that alliance given his lack of legitimacy following his suspect claim of electoral victory. He also merged and reinforced two militarized federal police agencies (roughly equivalent to the U.S. FBI and ATF), an action of dubious constitutionality. Columnist Carlos Fazio, who closely follows the military, recently commented in the daily La Jornada that the mounting repression (e.g., in Atenco and Oaxaca) seems to reflect a "recomposition of Mexican authoritarianism," a more coercive variant than the old PRI patronage machine of fatter times.
Liliana offers to help pack the supplies, so we head off to Bela's. En route we encounter Roberto, the Italian who works in one of the human rights NGOs and stayed at my house during part of last year. He is agitated because he has been up all night at the hospital with his Dutch co-worker Jet, who delivered a stillborn baby. As he describes the situation and Liliana asks a few medical questions, it appears that a simple medical error may have been the cause of death. Roberto says Jet's partner's family, who are Mexican, all assembled at the hospital and took turns cradling the body of the dead infant and singing it lullabies, an experience that left his European sensibilities quite shaken. Death just seems so much more of a presence in everyone's lives and consciousness in Mexico.
We arrive to discover that the ever-resourceful Bela has already conscripted the guests in her small guesthouse operation to pack up the boxes, so there's no work left to be done. I go back to Peter and María Elena's house where I'm staying to finish my own preparation, and late that night I get confirmation that the trip is on and Ernesto will meet me at Bela's at 6:30 am to load the van and head for the jungle.
I had met Ernesto on several occasions over the years, but the trip gave me an opportunity to get to know him better. Originally from Veracruz, he moved to Chiapas after the 1994 rebellion and worked for several NGOs before founding his own. We arrive around 9:30 am in the first Caracol where he needs to gather some information from the Zapatista Junta de Buen Gobierno (Good Government Council, the rotating authorities for the region). He is working on a study of one of the newer paramilitary groups, OPDDIC, which has been staging provocative invasions of lands already "recovered" by Zapatistas from the wealthy landowners after 1994. It seems the agrarian reform officials have been working hand in hand with OPDDIC, offering quick legalization of the newly retaken lands as part of a carrot-and-stick strategy to induce Zapatistas to switch affiliations to OPDDIC. Apparently the Junta is in the middle of hearing some complicated cases when we arrive, so we end up waiting three hours until Ernesto can talk to them. It's a beautiful day, in the 70s and clear, surrounded by hills covered with a mix of tropical vegetation and pines reflecting the prized biodiversity of Chiapas.
We set out toward the next Caracol, and the road starts turning into a muddy mess of huge holes and puddles. We skid and slide and struggle over each hill, and finally we sink into a pit, stuck at an angle precariously perched at the edge of a steep drop. Another truck has gone off the other side of the road and is sunk in the mud, leaving only enough room for small vehicles to get by. A light 4-wheel-drive pickup scampers up the center of the road but sticks in the mud toward the top of the hill. After much pondering, we decide we can all pitch in to push the pickup out of the mud, and Ernesto stays behind with the van while I go ahead with the pickup to the Caracol to see if they can send help. I check in with the Vigilance Commission and explain the situation, and they start mobilizing a crew to go help.
Before they can head out, Ernesto arrives in the van. He reports that an army truck came and couldn't get past them on the road, so the soldiers attached a chain to the van and used their truck to pull, but the van just turned diagonally and was in danger of slipping off the hillside, so they had to stop; but now they couldn't release the chain or the van would tumble over the edge. At that point a truckload of Zapatista community folks came, and they tied ropes to the other end of the van and anchored them around trees, so the army truck could pull the front of the van without the back end slipping over the hillside. It worked! - a rare instance of army/Zapatista/NGO collaboration! As Ernesto recounted the story of the army's arrival, at one point he said "they chained me up," then he hastened to clarify, "I mean they hooked up a chain to the van--because the other would have been possible too with the army!" And everyone had a good laugh.
After waiting our turn, we went in to see the Junta. They were very pleased and grateful to receive the donated school supplies. I also explained that I wanted to continue my research in the remaining municipio that I hadn't visited. I told them about the book project and gave them a copy of a letter that the authors had jointly written, asking permission to write about the autonomous communities and proposing to discuss drafts of each chapter with the Juntas in our respective regions. After a brief consultation among themselves in Tzeltal, the Junta gave me the "lek ay" (approval), and promised to give me a letter of authorization later in the evening for my visit to the municipio.
I repair to the cafeteria for a welcome bowl of beans and chat with the solidarity workers who run the place as a fundraiser for Zapatista schools, a woman from the Basque Country and a Mexican man and woman. They are eager for news from the "outside world," which strikes me as amusing since they are only a few hours from town, but in fact they don't often have the opportunity to make the trip. At 9 pm I pick up my letter from the Junta, who are still hard at work, and I turn in early so I can find a truck heading toward my destination. The camp where visitors usually stay is being used to store cement blocks they are making for a construction project, but I sweep off the cement dust from some wooden planks and stretch out my sleeping bag to crash.
I catch a truck around 4:30 am and then take the opportunity to have a hearty breakfast and strong coffee in town, since it may be awhile before I see those again. Then I go to the lot behind the marketplace where trucks and buses pick up passengers and cargo bound for jungle communities. I ask around for vehicles leaving for the community I'll call Santa María, seat of the autonomous municipality, and after a couple of hours a truck is leaving that I'm told is heading there. I'm dropped off at a village that turns out to be the wrong one, and I realize that there are many communities named after the same saint. Fortunately it is also a Zapatista community. Nobody knows how to get to the other Santa María, but they suggest I wait until a guy who went into town for a load of sand returns and he might know the way. The sand is for an oven project that some Italian volunteers are working on. I hang out talking to the Italians and playing chess with a Spaniard who has tagged along to help them. The guy with the truckload of sand shows up and doesn't know the way either, so I wait by the roadside for a ride back to town to try again.
Back at the depot, I get directed to the right truck, and after an hour or so of piling on an impossible amount of cargo and passengers, we lurch off down the jungle canyon, something like riding a bucking bronco for a couple of hours as we bounce and swerve through clouds of dust.
Asking around in Santa María, I am directed to the house of one of the autonomous councilmembers. His wife speaks no Spanish, but his kids tell me he's out gathering firewood, and they pull up a chair outside for me to rest. I doze after the long journey, and after a couple of hours a man I´ll call Juan arrives with his burro loaded with firewood. I give him the letter from the Junta and explain my purpose, and he says the next morning I can meet with the autonomous council and work out a plan of visits to the communities. We take turns showering in the little shed where they've rigged up a hose bringing water from the stream, a real treat to wash away the layers of caked mud. Juan's wife kindly brings me a bowl of fried eggs with tortillas and a cup of sweet watery coffee. I eat in the dirt-floor house as chickens run in and out.
Juan is a reserved man in his late 40s with a grave expression. He tells me he came here as a young man, shortly after the ejido was founded in 1975 by a group that petitioned the government for land under the old agrarian reform law. He knows that peasants' constitutional right to land has since ended with the neoliberal "reforms" of the 1990s. He is proud of the Zapatista struggle for land rights, and he tells me of some of the productive projects they have started in the region involving raising sheep and chickens, planting vegetables, etc. He is concerned that education has fallen behind in this municipio, since funding is limited and many communities have been unable to build schools.
Juan shows me to the community house which will be my sleeping quarters, a kind of large meeting hall with a cement floor where I stretch out my sleeping bag. A few other guys come by to chat, asking the usual questions about how far away my country is, how many hours by bus or plane, what crops we grow, and if there's work there for Mexicans. Migration is always a topic of conversation, now that the rural subsistence crisis has fueled a new flow of labor migration from poor Southern states like Chiapas that are not traditional sending states. They tell me that out of about 100 families in this village (which is split between Zapatistas and other organizations), 15 or 20 have someone in the U.S. working at any given time. They are aware of the risks of the passage and exploitative working conditions for migrants, but those who make it and manage to save some money can return in a year or two and put a corrugated tin roof on their house, and maybe buy a calf or two.
Friday morning around 10:00 I am brought to see the council and whoever else they could round up, about 20 guys of varying ages (no women). I explain my purpose and they seem a bit confused, unsure exactly what I want to know, probably not accustomed to being interviewed. Juan had told me they rarely get visitors out here, and I could tell by the way the children gathered to stare that a kaxlán was an unusual sight in these parts. But as I started to ask about the history of the community, the floodgates opened and everyone wanted to join in telling part of the story. They had struggled for their land rights under the agrarian reform in the 1970s. The wealthy landowner had lived in the faraway state capital of Tuxtla and owned many lands and business, including a hotel in Ocosingo. "The late Don Mario," as they still respectfully referred to him, used to pay them 5 pesos a day (US 50 cents) "when he felt like it," and rented them a little corner of bad land to grow their corn in exchange for part of the crop, 10 zontes (a zonte is 400 ears of corn) per hectare--about half the production in a typical year, leaving barely enough for survival. In a bad year when they couldn't make the 10 zontes, they had to work off their debt with extra labor. Now since the Zapatista rebellion they have new collective production projects to supplement incomes in the county, such as sheep and chicken-raising and vegetable plots, financed with start-up money from a Spanish solidarity group. The projects began in 4 of the 14 communities in the county, and each collective splits the proceeds between the county and the community. The county's share goes into a revolving fund to start up similar projects in the other communities until all 14 are eventually covered. It's a constant struggle against animal and plant disease, and they note that the government's agronomists and veterinarians "just sit in their office in the city, they never come out here to the countryside."
At the end of the meeting they all chip in suggestions as to which other communities I should visit. I tell them I'd like to visit a mix of historic ejidos and newly recovered lands, and see some of the productive projects they had mentioned. They come up with a list of 7 villages, disappointed that I won't have time to visit all 14 on this trip, and urge me to come back another time to see the rest.
In the afternoon a compa comes to take me to the next village which I'll call Nopal, a 20-minute truck ride away. He presents me to one of the community leaders I'll call Arturo who takes me to his house, where we sit on the dirt patio on a hillside with a spectacular view of the valley.
I am amused to see that they have used one of the plastic campaign posters for PRI presidential candidate Madrazo as a door to their outhouse. Arturo, a friendly man in his 50s, tells me a bit of his family story as chickens and pigs and dogs and turkeys and kids run about. Some of the kids pull makeshift toys on a string, while others are playing a variant of cops & robbers called "migra y pollero," where the Border Patrol agent chases the migrant-smugglers. Arturo's wife plies me with food, first fried eggs and beans, later slices of sugary boiled squash and roasted seeds and oranges.Nopal is a ranchería, a small independent farm settlement, on land purchased long ago by Arturo's grandfather from the landowner. But by Arturo's generation there was no land left to divide up, so he was left to roam as far as the neighboring state of Tabasco in search of work on lands of the wealthy landowners and ranchers. In the 1970s when the landless peasants of nearby Santa María and two other areas organized to occupy lands and demand titles under the agrarian reform, people in Nopal didn't participate because they were afraid of the army and Public Security forces, who were sent in by the landlord to burn the houses of the uppity peasants. But after a fruitless 9-year struggle to legally solicit their own lands under the agrarian reform, Arturo and the others here joined the clandestine Zapatista movement and they successfully recovered land. Now Arturo has to hike 2-1/2 hours to his milpa, but he is thrilled to have land to work, free from the arbitrary authority of the landlord, and he plans to continue living on this little plot in Nopal where he has carefully planted an array of fruit trees and flowers, where his children attend a Zapatista autonomous school and he has free access to the Zapatista clinic down the road in Santa María.
Arturo is pulling radio operator duty that night, so he insists I sleep on his mattress. He comes back at the crack of dawn and is hard at work splitting firewood, after being up all night on the radio. His wife brings us breakfast of coffee and sweetrolls, then I sit on the patio watching the fog roll through the valley while Arturo goes for a bath. We go downhill for the community meeting, about 70 men and women sitting on opposite sides of the wooden church. Some of my first questions are about the history of the community, and they decide to send for an 82-year-old man who is the only surviving member of the original group of founders. When the elder arrives, villagers kiss his hand or present their infants for him to bless by touching their foreheads. The old man recounts the tale of their virtual slavery in times of the baldío, the traditional free peasant labor for the landlord. A group of 20 of them had gotten together to buy a little piece of marginal land from the landlord, working off their debt through years of hard labor. It occurs to me that they were something like the "Free Coloreds" in the U.S. slavery era. The younger community members pick up the story from there, of their years of unsuccessful attempts to gain adequate land by exercising their legal rights under the agrarian reform, and then the Zapatista clandestine movement and the 1994 rebellion that led to successful land "recovery" when the three rich landlords who owned the entire valley fled. "They were afraid because they knew that their actions had been wrong, that they had a debt with us," one explained.
Afterwards Arturo takes me back to his house for a lemonade. "You know the guy you were talking to with the checkered shirt?," he asks. "He's from the Committee. His struggle name is ___." I suddenly realize I've met a member of the Clandestine Revolutionary Indigenous Committee, the Zapatista rebel leadership, a humble guy living like everyone else in the middle of nowhere.
Another compa comes to get me for the journey to the next community, which I'll call El Pinar. He picks up a horse along the way, and we take turns riding and walking the 2-1/2 hour road up and down the hills, stopping to bathe in a stream along the way.

El Pinar is a tiny ranchería of 14 families, 4 of them Zapatista, who also have recovered land down the road at a place I'll call La Alegría. They are pleased to have a visitor, and the mom brings me a bowl of chicken broth and tortillas with sweet coffee. Children take turns shooing away the chickens from the coffee beans that are spread out on plastic sheets drying in the sun in the front yard. We meet in one of their houses, and I learn that the 4 families are still struggling to maintain a school for the 10 children. They had a volunteer teacher from a nearby county for six months, then one from Spain, then they enrolled two of the older daughters in teacher training in the Zapatista county seat. The young women started teaching while learning, but the schoolhouse with its cardboard roof caved in during recent wind and rainstorms, so the four families are painstakingly saving to buy building materials to start over.
I stay up talking with one of the sons, who joined "The Organization" in 1994 and waxes enthusiastic about the struggle. If we're going to die, he tells me, we might as well fight to try to make things better for our kids. He points out across the expanse of valley where the rich landlord once had his hacienda house, and further down the valley where the landlord had once sent armed men to chop down a cornfield planted by defiant peasants--a traumatic event in local lore that several people have already recounted. Eventually I stretch out my sleeping bag on the floor and crash.
In the morning a radio is blaring a station from Guatemala, advertising courses in English, "the language of success." One of the other sons comes to fetch me after mom has brought me more chicken broth, and we set off for the recovered land settlement I'll call La Alegría. We stop to pick up a mule along the way to carry my backpack, and after an hour's brisk walk through the mountains we arrive.
It's Sunday, December 24 when we arrive, and everyone is in church. Gradually they filter out, the women going home to cook and the men congregating outside the community store to play cards, chat, tend the radio station, rake coffee beans drying in the sun, and herd a small flock of sheep that represent a project started with funds from a Spanish NGO. I hang out talking with the guys, and one of the two who has been assigned to attend visitors takes me back to his house for lunch, beans and tortillas and an unidentifiable stew which I prefer not to ask about. We go back to sit in the soccer field in front of the store, watching the Sunday afternoon slip by. Around 2:00 pm someone blows a few blasts on a cow's horn, and the community starts to assemble. We meet in the church, and the catechist, a middle-aged man, translates. This is recovered land, settled by 42 Zapatista families who came from the surrounding rancherías to take the landlord's ranch and plant corn after the rebellion. They also grow a bit of coffee, though it's barely worth it at the current price of US1.50 a kilo, and they are amazed to hear that U.S. consumers pay ten times that much for coffee. I ask my standard closing question, what are the most important changes in their lives since 1994. Now we're not working for a boss, they explain, so everything we grow with our own effort, we keep. One man reflects thoughtfully, "We see that we're no longer in the days of the mozo (fieldhand), but with unfair trade the way it is, it's like we're not entirely free. And those poor people who are with the government, receiving handouts, it's like they're still slaves."
There's more hanging out and card-playing in the afternoon. I spend the night in the radio room, not exactly sleeping but half-dozing through the crackle of the radio, the snoring of the radio operator, the blaring music and firecrackers from a wedding celebration at the neighboring ejido, the constant barking of every dog in the community, and the roosters starting around 4:00 am.
There doesn't seem to be any special celebration for Christmas, just an extra service in the church on the evening of the 24th, sparsely attended. Later a compa explains that there's no money for a community fiesta. I ask what days are celebrated with fiestas here, and he says just May 3rd, the day when indigenous people go into thge mountains to the source of their streams, with drums and flutes and prayers and offerings for good rains for the coming planting season.
On the morning of the 25th, a young boy is sent to fetch me and bring me back to his house where his mother gives me coffee and hojuelas, sugared frybread. The women hover by the fire while the menfolk are served at the table. The dad doen't speak much Spanish, but he tells me he came from a little rancho where there wasn't enough land to pass on to him and his brothers, so he came here as part of the land recovery. I go back and chat with the guy who is on radio and sheep-tending duty today.
He tells me he talked to the next community I'm scheduled to visit, which I'll call Las Palmas, and they're sending someone to guide me "al rato," in awhile, the catch-all time expression that can mean anytime in the course of the day.We set out around 9:00 am, a muddy hike of about an hour along jungle trails, up and down steep hills with occasional clearings and spectacular views of the valley. My guide scrambles nimbly as I huff and puff, and when we arrive I'm caked with mud and he's neat and clean. Almost everyone in Las Palmas is away in the fields or chopping wood or doing other tasks when I arrive. I bathe with a bucket of water, wash clothes, and talk with a couple of guys who are around the crumbling remains of the old hacienda house, now used as the schoolhouse. They bring me a huge bowl of scrambled eggs with hot sauce. By the afternoon everyone is assembled and we meet in the schol. The education promoter, a teenage kid with a deformed foot, translates. There are 38 families here, and the elders recall the bitter days of the finca when the landlord paid them 30 US cents a day for hard labor from sunup to sundown, and let them plant a little corn on a bit of land in exchange for them planting it over with pasture grass after the harvest.
The school here has been struggling since they started it in 2000, with a series of education promoters from nearby communities lasting a couple of months each. Nobody here has had much education, but they finally recruited a couple of young volunteers from the community who augmented their 3rd-grade education with teacher training, and now they teach first and second grade--but only four days a week, because they have to tend their own cornfield and the community is too poor to offer them any corn.
At the end of the meeting, they stay for an animated discussion of the upcoming celebration of January 1st, anniversary of the Zapatista rebellion. Afterwards a compa invites me home for dinner, more eggs and tortillas. Then I retire to the schoolhouse to write some notes and draw a crowd of fascinated kids, who don't see much writing and have never seen cursive script. It starts raining, which means it's going to be a very mudy early morning trek to the community I'll call Rancho Viejo.
A young compa stops by in the early morning to chat, and he asks about work in the U.S., a constant theme in these parts. He tells me the polleros (smugglers) here charge US$900, which is at the low end of the range I've heard in different parts of the state. The bargain-basement smugglers leave their passengers at the border, while the deluxe trip costing around $2,000 usually includes delivery at a workplace. Of course nobody has that kind of money, and the moneylenders charge 10% monthly interest, which takes a hefty bite out of U.S. earnings. Many from this area have been stopped at the border and sent back, he tells me, but the polleros return the fee after three failed attempts to cross. My guide arrives for the trip to Rancho Viejo, a fairly strenuous hike on muddy hilly trails. He is a thirtyish man who hops agilely along the trails as I struggle with my backpack (Note to self: Pack less!). Upon arriving, someone blows a conch shell to summon the community. The meeting in the church is fairly brief, as it seems the men are anxious to get back to the fields. The most interesting thing I learn is from an informal conversation with the young health promoter, who tells me he went to work for two months in agricultural harvests in the state of Jalisco. He said some of the bosses were mean, following them around and telling them to work harder or they'd be fired. He said the Organization only gives permission around here for people to leave for 2 months for migratory labor (i.e., within Mexico). Those who exceed the limit are punished, he says, either with community service or they are sentenced to "a few days of rest to think about whether or not they really want to be in the struggle."
Two young kids are dispatched to escort me to a community I'll call El Limón, a half hour away. Most of the men are already away in the fields, but the radio operator takes me to the home of one of the leaders who is resting from playing keyboards all night a a fiesta in a nearby village. He shows me to the church to rest, and sends his kids later with a bowl of delicious tamales and a tangerine. Finally everyone assembles in the afternoon after a few blasts of the cow's horn. Just as the conversation begins, a scowling man standing at the edge of where everyone is seated on benches demands to see my letter of authorization from the Junta. I explain that I left it with the autonomous municipal authorities at the county seat, but they can radio back there if there's any doubt. No, he says, the meeting is over, you have to leave. I'm surprised and disappointed, but autonomy means each community makes its own decisions. As I hike back to the previous village to spend the night, I wonder whether the guy who stopped the meeting was one of the mandos militares, leaders of the military part of the movement, whose security concerns sometimes clash with the civilian leadership structures. The folks in the previous village are also a bit surprised to see me, and when I explain what happened they do radio back to the municipal council for verification, then they put me up for the night and I start the journey back to San Cristóbal early the next morning.
Despite the disappointment at the end, it has been a very productive and informative trip, and actually I made such good time that now I'll be able to attend the four-day Zapatista encuentro in the highlands before I have to return to the U.S.
Friday, May 26, 2006
education for liberation
click here.


Thursday, May 18, 2006
the strangeness of San Cristóbal
Marcos had said the delegates on the Other Campaign would stay put in Mexico City until the 200 or so Atenco prisoners are freed, but it doesn’t seem likely that the government will be in any hurry to release the leaders. Human rights groups continue to release accounts of beatings, rape and sexual abuse of detainees, most of whom are now on a hunger strike. The Jesuit human rights center Miguel Agustín Pro in Mexico City interviewed some of the police, who acknowledged that they were armed with live ammunition and had orders to beat people whenever they were out of sight of the media. The Mexican television duopoly, Televisa and TV Azteca, continue to peddle the line that the protesters are a fringe group of violent extremists, and repeatedly broadcast the same clip of some protesters attacking police, carefully omitting the overwhelming violence in the other direction. The New York Times helpfully reported that social movements ranging from Atenco peasants to the Zapatistas were all irrelevant because Mexico is a functioning democracy, which prompted me to write the following letter to the editor that apparently didn’t meet the criteria for “All the News that’s Fit to Print”:
To the Editor:
As a political scientist researching social movements in Mexico, I was dismayed to see those movements dismissed because “Mexico has a functioning democracy” (“Marcos Back in Public Eye in Mexico,” May 10).
Competitive elections are necessary but not sufficient for democracy, as evidenced here in Mexico by the government’s brutal repression of protesting farmers and flower vendors that left a 14-year-old dead and over 200 arrested. Amnesty International has joined global expressions of concern over documented beatings and rape of detainees.
Impunity for abusive officials, and extreme socioeconomic inequality (rivaling South Africa, by UN measures), help explain why the Zapatistas’ “other campaign” has resonated widely among a population frustrated by empty promises of change after the 2000 election. Equating elections with democracy blinds us to realities driving Mexico’s number two export–-migrants-–and to our own defects: torture in the name of national security, and vigilante killings of migrant workers.
Last Thursday there was a march in San Cristóbal, one of many around the country, in protest against the repression at Atenco.


Some 800 people participated, a large turnout by local standards, including delegations of indigenous people from the pacifist community of Las Abejas ("The Bees") and from the poor peripheral neighborhood of La Hormiga. The response from people on the street was surprisingly friendly, with nearly everyone taking a flier. Behind the scenes the organizing for the march was fraught with division, especially between some of the anarchists (mostly foreigners) who wanted to block roads and a group of local NGOs that thought such actions would just play into the anti-protest hysteria that the government has been whipping up. But working that all out is part of what La Otra Campaña is all about, learning to work in coalitions across a fractious span of the left.
Speaking of which, the house has been full of a diverse collection of people in this limbo period when it’s not clear if anyone can go out to communities. A couple of anarchist Catalans who are part of the squatter movement in Barcelona were staying here, along with an Italian human rights worker who just arrived to work with one of the local peace education/observer groups. Sometimes it felt as though the anarchists and socialists were re-fighting the Spanish Civil War, but we all had a good time; and it’s been nice to have company at a time when I would otherwise be going stir-crazy after two weeks in San Cristóbal, a pleasant and thoroughly unreal town which one of the Swedish human rights workers referred to the other day as "a doll-house."
On Tuesday I went to the university for a seminar, which turned out to be one of those highly academic and abstract discussions that seemed out of touch with what’s going on in the here and now. In the chit-chat before we got started, one of the anthropologists commented on how San Cristóbal is a kind of splicing of different worlds that rarely intersect, and as an example she described a conversation she recently had with a coleta (member of the San Cristóbal local non-indigenous elite), which made her realize that almost all her friends are intellectual and cosmopolitan types from other parts of the country. It seems the coleta asked what she did for a living, and when she confessed to being an anthropologist, the neighbor responded, "Oh! Tell me, what do you think of the Indians?"
Besides the provincial coleto types who are living in a time warp of faded colonial glory, and the more worldly non-locals who are here in the backwater by some twist of fate or anthropological interest, there are also of course the indigenous people (now a majority in San Cristóbal counting those who live in the poor colonias that ring the city, but invisible to those who choose not to see). Then there are at least two categories of foreigners: the tourists (mostly Europeans of the younger/backpacking variety, but some middle-aged ones seeking sun and/or a New Age experience on the "Mayan Route"); and the resident NGO/activist clique. And it’s true, the worlds they inhabit in this small town don’t intersect much. After the seminar a colleague kindly offered me a ride back toward the center of town, and on the way politely inquired how my research was going. When I replied that it was momentarily stalled due to the Zapatista red alert, it became clear that this had never occurred to her, since nobody in the world she inhabits ever travels to Zapatista territory–-and this was an anthropologist who studies indigenous issues in Chiapas!
Looking for an excuse to get out of town, yesterday I went with Mariana (a much more politically engaged anthropologist) back to Ocosingo to try again to nail down an interview with Pedro Chulín, the paramilitary leader who had stood us up a couple of weeks ago when Bernard and I had an appointment to interview him. Of course he wasn’t there, and we tried to salvage something out of the two-hour trip by going to some offices of government officials and one of the priísta peasant organizations, but nobody was available for an appointment. Just when we were ready to give up and head home, we came across a long line of indigenous women waiting for their welfare payments from the government’s Oportunidades program, which claims to reach one in five Mexicans. We decided to strike up a conversation with a couple of women in line, and it turned out to be a much more revealing interview than we would have had with any of the government bureaucrats.
The women were remarkably clear in their analysis of the government program and their own situation. They receive payments contingent on sending their kids to government schools and going for medical check-ups. The payments can be as little as 150 pesos (around $13) every two months, for which first the coordinators have to make a trip into town to hand in paperwork, then all the women receiving the payment have to come in together the next day and wait in line most of the day for their money. These women had walked from their village into the city, since the bus fare of 30 pesos was prohibitive. They told us they needed the money because they were desperately poor, because they had never had an opportunity to get an education and therefore had no job prospects, and their husbands owned no land and had to work as day laborers for landowners for 30 or 40 pesos a day. They understood that sending their kids to school was a good thing, though their children also had to walk into town for school, and the parents had to spend part of their meager Oportunidades money on school supplies and uniforms, and the money wasn’t enough to buy them shoes for their long walk. They had heard that their kids might have job prospects if they could study computing, but that involved private classes that cost 90 pesos a week, way out of their range of possibilities. They resented the requirement of a monthly medical exam, which they found onerous and intrusive; especially gynecological exams by male doctors who they said were "meanies" (enojones) and always pressured them to get sterilized, while their husbands pressured them on the other side to have more children. They found the medical consultations useless because if they needed medicine, they were given only the prescription, but of course they couldn’t afford to buy the medicine. The coordinators from each village are also required to go to training workshops every month, where they said they were never told about women’s rights (contrary to the claim of program officials) but instead are taught to "be obedient." The women concluded, "They just want to control us. The government wants to make slaves out of us."
It's interesting to ponder why some people, recognizing structural injustice (such as discrimination that has blocked access to education for themselves and their children, and landlessness), conclude that there is no alternative but to accept what they regard as a humiliating and enslaving "aid" program. Others on the other hand conclude that they should fight for land, education, and basic dignity, and consciously choose to refuse the crumbs of aid.
Back in San Cristóbal, part of the strange and tense atmosphere these days includes an escalation of incidents of harassment of anyone involved in indigenous issues, human rights, or The Other Campaign. After last Thursday’s march, one of the Tzotzil organizers was accosted on the street by two strangers who pushed him around and drew their fingers across their throats, while another woman involved in the event was thrown against a wall and told not to get involved in things that don’t concern her. I’ve had a series of minor incidents at the house, including phone messages consisting of police sirens or muffled voices and music, and the other night someone rang the doorbell in the middle of the night. Also a few days ago someone came to the door to deliver a letter from the government of the state of Chiapas to one of the local peace activists–whose office is a few blocks from here, and there’s no particular reason why the government should know that I know her. All pretty small stuff, but I reported it to the human rights center, where they’re keeping track of what has become a very long list of incidents, with the more threatening and violent acts directed against Mexicans and the fuzzier stuff for foreigners (since the political costs would be higher for the government).
Friday, May 05, 2006
Zapatista red alert
On Wednesday I set off for Ocosingo with Bernard, hoping to interview paramilitary leader Pedro Chulín, and P. who planned to go on to the Caracol to interview the Junta. Chulín had given us a 7:00 a.m. appointment, but when we got to his house his wife told us that he had gone back to the ranch to check on his cattle (about five hours away, and no way to contact him to find out when he planned to return). Chulín is an indigenous cacique (boss) who has built something of a following and a fortune as a powerbroker. His house is huge and tasteless, decorated with enormous cement swans on the outside and painted in garish colors, like the houses of organized crime chieftains and other nouveau riche.

The photo gallery in his living room included one of Chulín with his arm around Roberto Madrazo, the presidential candidate from the hardline "dinosaur" wing of the PRI. Bernard and I went off to do other interviews and came back in a couple of hours, but still no sign of the Man. So we took a truck a couple of hours down the road and hiked another half hour or so to a tiny community where we had been given an open invitation by one of the Junta members to go visit him anytime. When we got there, it turned out he was back on duty at the Caracol and wasn’t home, but his sons welcomed us like family.
The community was a ranchería, basically consisting of the Junta member whom I’ll call Felipe and his four sons and their families. It was May 3, the day of celebration of the sources of water at the start of the planting season (or Day of the Holy Cross). When we arrived we were greeted by one of the sons whom I’ll call Francisco, who apologized for being covered with soot because in the middle of their Holy Cross celebration, someone noticed that the fire from one of the fields that was being burned in preparation for planting had caught the neighboring woods and was getting out of control. So the family had just spent the last couple of hours putting out the fire. Now they were back, and everyone knelt down in the dirt for prayers. Then they invited us inside for leftovers from the feast, a delicious chicken broth with chayote (green cactus-like vegetable), and home-made soft white cheese from their small dairy operation of ten cows. Francisco turned out to be quite a talker, so he told us the whole family history in great detail. His father, the patriarch of the little community, had been orphaned young and had to fend for himself as a merchant. The family joined the Organization, and paramilitaries killed two of Francisco’s brothers. They wanted to stay and fight, but they were relocated to recovered land near the Caracol, where they worked in collective for a few years. They carefully saved their resources, investing in a few cattle when some Zapatistas were selling them cheap because they feared that the ranchers and military would launch a new offensive and take or kill all their animals. But the family believed that the movement had a future, and their investment allowed them to build up a small herd, which they then sold to buy this plot of 48 hectares (from a non-Zapatista small farmer who was happy to sell a little of his land at a low price to a Zapatista family as a kind buffer between his land and a larger Zapatista settlement with which he had had conflicts). Through hard work and imagination, they parlayed that into a small corn and cattle farm, going without new clothes or toys for the kids in order to buy a little machine for chopping up hay to fatten the cattle; then slowly developing a profitable cheese business. It was an interesting example of a different breed of Zapatistas, small farmers who were entrepreneurial yet had a passionate commitment to social justice and the Organization.
In the evening I played chess with the kids until it was too hard to see the pieces in the candlelight, then Bernard and I strung our hammocks in the one-room schoolhouse and crashed. In the morning we kept the kids company while they milked the cows, then said goodbye to Francisco who headed out to his fields. His wife insisted on giving us care packages of cheese, and we said our farewells to the families and headed back. Fortunately a truck came by almost as soon as we got to the road, but halfway to town the truck in front of us carrying two cows tipped and went into the ditch, so there was a delay while everyone pitched in to pull it out.
We got back to Ocosingo and checked back with the paramilitary leader, who still hadn’t returned. As we stood in the marketplace preparing to go our separate ways, we saw one of the Zapatista education promoters I’ll call Roberto, whom we both knew from one of the remote communities. We stopped to greet him and he asked where we were off to. I said I was on my way to the Caracol, and he looked surprised and said there’s nobody there! What do you mean?, I asked, confused. There’s a red alert since the Atenco massacre, the Caracoles are closed, he said. Roberto quickly filled us in on the news we had missed while we were out in the community: There had been a protest in the vicinity of San Salvador Atenco in central Mexico not far from the capital, site of a radical peasant organization called the Frente de Pueblos en Defensa de la Tierra (People’s Front in Defense of the Land), which in 2002 successfully blocked an airport project that would have displaced peasants from their lands. Anyway, it seems the FPDT were supporting a group of flower vendors who were being driven out of their spot in the market by the authorities. The feds descended in riot gear and all hell broke loose, and in the end two of the protesters (including one child) were killed. More federal forces were called in and started doing a house-to-house sweep, and at last count 275 people had been detained, wounded or disappeared.
So Bernard and I stopped at an internet cafe to get caught up on the news, then I returned to San Cristóbal since the Zapatista territories were now closed for the alert. Back in town I ran into P., who had returned to the house because he was unable to get to the Caracol for the same reason. Reflecting ruefully on his recent experiences in trying to get the Mexican state to face up to its defects of an unaccountable military and lack of an independent judiciary, and now seeing the gap between official and actual Chiapas, P.’s parting words before he left for the border-town underworld of Tapachula were: "When you start to scratch the surface in Mexico, you realize things are even worse than you thought. It’s painful."
Being grounded in San Cristóbal during a Zapatista red alert seems like deja vu, as this was exactly the situation when I arrived here in June of 2005, when the Zapatistas were preparing to issue the Sixth Declaration of the Lacandón Jungle and launch the Other Campaign. That time it lasted a couple of weeks, and all the NGO/activist folks who normally worked in communities were starting to go a little stir crazy in town, getting tired of waiting and speculating. People eventually started using the time to catch up on city chores, get together with folks who are usually not all in town at the same time, and throw lots of parties. My guess is that this time the alert will be shorter, but nobody is in much of a party mood in the wake of Atenco.
The repression at Atenco seems in part an indirect attack on the Zapatistas. The FPDT were subscribers to the Zapatista Sixth Declaration, Marcos and company had just passed through Atenco, and members of the peasant group were in fact serving as a security detail for the Zapatista leaders on the Other Campaign swing through Mexico City. Maybe the government figured the moment wasn’t (yet) politically favorable for a direct blow against the Zapatista leadership, but perhaps they calculated that this would have a chilling effect on the Other Campaign, or maybe it was intended as a trial balloon to see if they could get away with a direct move against the Zapatistas. In any event, the new alliance strategy of the Zapatistas since the Sixth Declaration meant that the Zapatistas had a political commitment to help galvanize a response to this repression against an allied group. One of the chilling aspects of this attack has been the reporting in the mainstream Mexican media, with TV Azteca in particular using highly inflammatory language to vilify the peasant group as violent extremists. Once again, this is an indication that the Other Campaign, with its invitation to broaden the national debate to more fundamental issues than electioneering, is touching some raw nerves.
Sunday, April 30, 2006
waiting for the rains
I had been given the names of a couple of Zapatista tour guides at the ruins at Toniná, so that made the tour more interesting as we got commentary comparing the hierarchical structures of ancient Mayan and contemporary Mexican government. Our guide, whom I'll call Melvin, also worked as an apprentice to the head archeologist and was avidly learning everything he could, and he proudly showed us places where he had done the reconstruction himself. At one point we asked if a piece of structure was original, and Melvin replied with a smile, "That's from the Tzeltal era"--meaning his own ethnic group, who are descendants of the ancient Maya. It was a good reminder that history is continuous and "authentic" representation of a culture is an elusive construct.
On Tuesday we went up to Oventic, the closest Zapatista Caracol in the highlands less than an hour from San Cristóbal.

The students got the broad overview from the Junta and the Information Commission, then had a chance to talk with a young woman education promoter and a young man who worked as health coordinator in the regional Zapatista clinic. The 19-year-old education promoter talked about the sacrifice involved in leaving her home community and living at her workplace, and the health coordinator had some interesting reflections about the cultural and educational aspects of preventive/primary health care. I think talking to those young volunteers and seeing their quiet dedication made more of an impact than all the analytical talks the delegation had with think tanks and NGOs in San Cristóbal.
On Tuesday and Wednesday nights there were panels in town featuring the two past bishops of Chiapas, Samuel Ruiz and Raúl Vera.

Don Samuel, like the famous Archbishop Romero of El Salvador, began his tenure as a very traditional bishop and ended as a committed Liberation Theology practitioner and champion of the poor and marginalized. Dubbed the "red bishop" by his detractors from the San Cristóbal elite, he learned indigenous languages and traveled the back roads and was affectionately known as "Tatik," our father, in indigenous communities. Many of the catechists trained by his diocese would become radicalized and join the Zapatista movement (not exactly what the bishop had in mind, but the gods work in mysterious ways), and Don Samuel was tapped as mediator between the government and rebels after the 1994 uprising. The Vatican continually tried to undercut him, first appointing the seemingly mainstream Raúl Vera as co-bishop. But to the Vatican's chagrin, Don Raúl too was converted by the reality he experienced in Chiapas. Don Samuel survived assassination attempts (hence his accompaniment by bodyguards on this occasion who followed him even to the bathroom). Finally the Vatican was able to invoke its retirement rules to force Don Samuel to step aside at age 75, and he moved to Querétaro north of Mexico City. Don Raul was then banished to the desert, transferred to serve as bishop in the northern state of Coahuila, and the colorless/conservative Bishop Felipe Arizmendi was wheeled in.
Don Raúl gave a press conference Tuesday night to discuss the scandal of a deadly mining accident in his new state. It was the first time I had heard him speak, and now I could imagine how his conversion must have occurred in Chiapas. He is detail-oriented and relentless in getting to the bottom of things, but also passionate in exposing what he considers to be wrong. He systematically laid bare all the malfeasance of mining company and government officials, documented their cover-ups, and presented results of his meticulous investigation into the powerful interlocking economic and political interests at work (including mining executive ties to Vamos México, the shady "philanthropic" foundation of First Lady Martha Sahagún (who has been compared to Evita Perón). He left no stone unturned, and by the end of the evening he was positively on fire as he denounced the callousness toward human life exhibited by the powerful. Commenting on the bishop's detailed knowledge of arcane topics such as coal mine degasification, one of the panelists noted with a chuckle that the government probably didn't realize that Don Raúl's first degree was in chemical engineering. And they thought they could keep him quiet by sending him to the desert!
The presentation the following night was a panel introducing the 2005 annual report of the Fray Bartolomé de Las Casas human rights center (FrayBa), of which Samuel Ruiz was founder and remains the honorary president. The report reflects the careful work of the center, documenting violations but also analyzing the changing strategies of repression. One commentator noted that the government now uses not only paramilitaries but also "para-police," a term she used to describe the rural indigenous organization OPDDIC. Don Samuel highlighted the report's focus on the government's skillful manipulation of the judicial system to allow "legal legitimation of human rights violations"; noting that adherence to the law is not the same as adherence to justice. There was also mention of the continued heavy military occupation of the conflict zones, partly hidden now as the troops are kept mostly in their barracks or spirited away on unknown missions, and the significant escalation of attacks on human rights defenders and journalists. Tellingly, the center has stopped including a section on "Recommendations" in their reports, noting that it's pointless since the government totally ignores independent human rights organizations.
Wednesday night the delegation left on the overnight bus to Oaxaca, and Thursday I ran around town taking care of odds and ends before leaving early Friday morning for the jungle. I'm up at 6:30 a.m. to get to Macondo at 8:30, just in time to catch a truck heading for the third of the four municipalities I'm working in. There were two other foreigners on the truck, but only when we all got off at the seat of the Zapatista autonomous municipality three hours later did we realize we had the same destination. They turned out to be Germans from Giessen, coming here as human rights observers through the FrayBa. The councilmembers here attend Friday afternoons and Saturdays, in addition to serving a 10-day stint on the regional Junta every two months during a three-year term. In between time, they scramble to attend their cornfields and family obligations.
The council receives me in the evening, and they remember me from previous visits. There is a brief moment of uncertainty when they ask if I had stopped at the Junta for a new letter of authorization, but I show them the old letter and explain that it was for multiple visits to communities in the municipality, and they're O.K. with that. We discuss which communities I might visit on this trip, and they tell me they think it is better if I don't travel to divided ejidos right now because there have been a lot of provocations by the paramilitary group OPDDIC, and the council feels responsible for the security of their visitors. This fit with other information I had heard that OPDDIC leader Pedro Chulín had recently lost his bid to be candidate for Congress, and some of his supporters were spoiling for a fight. The council tells me I can leave with them on Saturday afternoon when some of them would be headed down the nearby canyon where I'll be visiting four communities.
Saturday afternoon around 3:00 I'm waiting for word from the council when I see some of them gathering their backpacks and heading for a truck. Sure enough, they're headed out, so I barely have time to say goodbye to the Germans and fetch my damp clothes off the barbed wire and grab my backpack and hop on. The truck stops about ten minutes out of the village so the councilmembers can take a quick dip in the river and retrieve handfulls of fish from the mesh nets they had set the day before, a little protein to bring home. About a half hour down the road I'm dropped off at a a junction with two other compas heading down the same canyon. After a two hour hike at a rapid clip, mostly uphill with packs (me huffing and puffing and my companions floating effortlessly, of course), we arrive at a settlement I'll call San José del Arroyo. It's a beautiful spot nestled between two ranges of green hills, on land recovered from a rich rancher. Just 15 families live here, with plenty of land now for each of them plus collective lands that they work together to generate revenues for community projects.
The folks in San José greet me warmly, offer me something to eat, ask about the differences between life here and in the U.S., and put me up in the radio shack where I drift off to sleep to the sounds of the crackling CB radio. It rains softly overnight, which pleases everyone here because they're waiting for a few decent rains signaling the start of the rainy season so they can start planting their cornfields. All over the region a haze of smoke hangs in the hills as campesinos are burning brush, clearing patches of land as part of their slash-and-burn agricultural cycle.
Sunday morning the responsable of the community, a young man I'll call Pancho, brings me to his house where his wife offers me beans and tortillas and coffee. Pancho is an enthusiastic Zapatista who grew up in the movement, participating in land takeovers that were violently dislodged by the ranchers in the '80s (in which he saw several of his comrades killed), then fought in Ocosingo in '94 and participated in this land recovery in '97. He recounts how they found an arms cache buried on the landowner's property, with high-powered rifles and bombs "that were meant for us." He is also a catechist and enthusiastically shares his views on how the Zapatista movement is biblically based. He recounts the story of Exodus and compares it to their own struggle for liberation. Then he explains that the participation of women as Zapatista insurgents is consistent with the biblical story of Judith, who led her people in heroic resistance against a powerful army.
Sunday church service starts at 8:30 and people file into the small wooden building, including campesinos from surrounding ranchitos who are not Zapatistas, but come here for services. As Pancho explains, "We talk about the Organization in church too, maybe they'll wake up." Men sit on benches on one side, women on the other. After a few Our Fathers and Hail Marys, there is a reading of a Bible passage, about the wealthy landowner who is told that it's easier for a camel to pass through the eye of a needle than for a rich person to enter heaven. Then they break up into separate groups of men and women to discuss the meaning of the passage and its relevance for their lives, with a list of questions to spark discussion. After about 45 minutes they reunite back in church for further discussion together and clarification from Pancho, the catechist.
Then the service morphs into a community meeting. Marco, a quiet man who joined the Organization only seven months before (leaving his tiny ranchito to join the group here on recovered land), stands up to report shyly on a recent meeting to resolve a church/community problem. It seems the catequists of the region, who belong to non-Zapatista organizations, started hassling the Zapatistas and telling them the land recovered by Zapatistas should be divided among all the campesino organizations. Eventually the Zapatistas got fed up and left the group, holding their own separate meetings of catequists. Then the deacons stopped administering sacraments to the Zapatista communities, using the pretext that they had withdrawn from their region. Several years had gone by and there was a backlog of pending church weddings and baptisms, so they went to talk to a group of missionary women and ask them to intercede with the bishop. The plan now was to meet with deacons in another region, and if they also refused, then the bishop had apparently told the missionaries that he would have a priest come out from the parish in Ocosingo to perform the rites. As Pancho told me later, the problems had originated when conservative Bishop Arizmendi came in, but I guess he didn't want to be on record as denying services of a priest to communities in need.
The next item on the agenda was planning for the celebration of May 3, marking the start of the planting season, a day celebrated in these indigenous territories by going into the mountains to the water source where the elders pray for good rains. The Catholic Church, coopting the indigenous traditions it couldn't undo, has superimposed the holiday of the Holy Cross on that day, which is now typically celebrated with a blend of community picnic in the hills with prayers and with drum and flute music. Women take the lead in the discussion of how many tortillas and how much atole (sweetened rice water) each family should contribute for the community meal.
Afterwards the women retire and the men gather in front of the church to answer my questions. "The landowner was a real bastard," they tell me, who owned all the land in the entire canyon and worked the peasants long hours for $1.50 a day. He "loaned" them small patches of the worst land where they were allowed to plant some corn to feed themselves, but charged them in the form of labor, planting and fencing his cattle pastures. They were not allowed to take so much as an orange from the land. The 15 families here had come from the local area, recovering this land after the Zapatista uprising and attracting new members of the Organization to join them. Now they spoke proudly of planting their own land, enough to feed themselves without working for anyone else, as well as a collective patch that generated corn and income to feed their own community education and health promoters and take care of other collective needs. The women had also started a pig-raising collective, starting by pooling resources to buy and raise one pig, which they sold to buy two piglets to fatten, then sold those to buy three. As they explain, "Collective labor has great significance, it means we have unity, we all work together, we go drink pozol [corn gruel] in the fields together, we share what the land gives us." They tell me some OPDDIC members had tried to occupy their lands but they rallied a larege group of Zapatistas to start planting and refused to fall for the OPDDIC efforts to provoke violent confrontation.
My host Pancho brings me home for another meal, then we go to the river to bathe with his gaggle of kids. There's a fire-red sunset over the hills.

In the evening I hang out chatting with the night shift of radio operators, then all the men come over to watch old Mexican charro (cowboy) movies on a tiny black-and-white TV hooked up to a car battery, on a weak signal from a station in the neighboring state of Tabasco. Afterwards I fall asleep to the sounds of the whistling cicadas, the occasional whinnying of a horse, and the rumbling of the CB radio.
On Monday morning, Pancho fetches me at 6:00 for coffee, then he saddles up two horses for us to ride to the next community I'm scheduled to visit, which I'll call Pedregal. He has to make some purchases there at the bodega de abarrotes (general supply store/warehouse), which is a new project of the autonomous municipality. He insists on escorting me to avoid problems with other organizations like the paramilitary group OPDDIC. It's a beautiful ride through the valley, and we arrive in about an hour and a half. Most of the group in Pedregal are already in the fields, clearing or burning brush in preparation for planting. Those who are hanging around greet me like one of the family and put me up in an upstairs cement room in the crumbling remains of what was once the hacienda house. The large room in the downstairs attachment to the house has been outfitted with a new zinc roof (since what must have been the original wooden beams and red tile had crumbled away), painted, and now houses the new bodega. Electricity came to this community around six months ago when the Junta authorized an unofficial connection to the Federal power lines, and the solidarity group that supported the project donated a refrigerator and a computer.
The compa from the nearby village I'll call Nuevo Amanecer who is responsible for running the bodega comes over to ask if I know about computers, since he has a problem with the printer. I go help with the printer glitch and learn that the solidarity group that donated the computer gave him a crash course in accounting, but didn't get around to teaching him Excel so he could keep the books with a spreadsheet, so the computer was only being used to watch DVDs (Rambo and Schwartzenegger and Kung Fu movies). A typical shortcoming of "development aid." He asked if I could teach him, so I ended up spending the day giving Excel lessons, interrupted periodically whenever someone rode up on horseback to make a purchase through the window, or came around the front to load their purchases, heaving 30-kilo sacks of sugar and other supplies onto their backs, secured with a mecapal (rope sling) around their head for the long walk to their home village.
The bodega generates revenue for the autonomous municipality, and customers include non-Zapatistas as well as Zapatistas, all glad to save the time and expense of travel several hours to the nearest town. The warehouseman is a 30-year-old guy who didn't finish grade school and reads slowly, but he is a quick study and is delighted to learn to use a spreadsheet to ease his bookkeeping headaches. They are still novices at the business, and he tells me the merchants in town refuse to give them a wholesale discount, so they are trying to figure out if it might be worth an occasional run to the state capital--but that's about as far from the village as anyone has ever traveled, and they're not sure how to go about locating suppliers there.
A young man I'll call Joel brings me back to his house for a meal of eggs with chile, beans and tortillas, as chickens and dogs scramble around the dirt floor and smoke from the cooking fire fills a corner of the small wooden house, and grandma swings the youngest of his five kids in a tiny hammock rigged from a burlap sack and pieces of rope. Joel came here from a distant jungle region near Palenque and his wife is Ch'ol, so in addition to his native Tzeltal he speaks Ch'ol and decent Spanish and also some Tzotzil, since 10 of the 14 families here came from the faraway highlands, escaping both landlessness and paramilitary repression in the period after the Acteal massacre.
In the afternoon I meet with the community leaders. Their story is similar to the previous community, also on land recovered from the lord of the valley. But here the first group of land recoverers after '94 fell into problems fueled by alcohol, so the settlement had dissolved, and the Zapatistas brought in new groups of landless peasants from far-flung regions. Now they seemed to be a very close-knit community, with two young education promoters for the 33 kids and a collective cornfield, pasture and chile patch. Like the community of San José del Arroyo, they rent out pasture land for grazing of cattle owned by non-Zapatistas in the surrounding area. I suspect the practice of rental doesn't quite conform to Zapatista agrarian law, but perhaps it is overlooked since it generates income for struggling communities in resistance, helps stake claims to the land, and helps stabilize relations with non-Zapatista neighbors.
In the evening the bodega closes and computer lesson ends, and some of the guys gather outside the remains of the hacienda house/bodega with two guitars and a bass to sing ballads of the Zapatista rebellion and church songs in Tzeltal. Communities with electricity definitely stay up later than those without, and also attract a wild variety of large flying insects dive-bombing the light bulbs. I wonder what the former landowner would think if he could see this scene: his former peons relaxing and laughing on the veranda at night, his parlor converted into a communally-run peasant store, his pastures now dotted with healthy cornfields on the good flat patches of land where his valuable animals used to graze, and an autonomous schoolhouse with Zapata's image painted on the front--the old world turned upside down.
On Tuesday morning two young guys from the community loan me a horse and insist on escorting me to the next community which is only 45 minutes away, again to avoid potential problems with OPDDIC, which has several members in a village along the way. We arrive in the slightly larger community I'll call Venecia, and an older fellow I'll call Lorenzo lets me into the chapel so I'll have a shady spot to rest. After a couple of hours another middle-aged man I'll call Donaldo stops by to see where I'm coming from, exclaiming "That's great that you've come to visit!" Visitors seem to be a rare treat in this remote region, and the hospitality is a bit embarrassing. Donaldo brings me over to the one-room schoolhouse and tells me to wait while he finds something for me to eat.
I hang out all day in the schoolhouse waiting for everyone to come back from the fields for a meeting, and getting eaten alive by biting ants in the meantime. School is not in session today, and not much is happening in the village. People stop by from time to time and stare at the strange apparition of a visitor. Only a few speak some Spanish, and they explain in Tzeltal to their curious neighbors: He's from the United States! It's five hours away by airplane! He says they don't eat tortillas there, they eat bread!! And they grow wheat because it's cold country! The thought of life without tortillas seems to evoke a mixture of disbelief and pity, and everyone who hears it has to repeat it to be sure they heard right.
In the late afternoon when everyone is back from the fields, Lorenzo comes over and blows a few blasts on a cow's horn to summon all the men for an assembly outside the schoolhouse. Manuel, the one guy in the community who speaks pretty good Spanish, translates for me. Each question seems to generate about ten minutes of animated discussion in Tzeltal among the villagers before someone gives a summarized response that is translated into "castilla," the language of the foreigner-Castilians. I'm sure I'm missing a lot of the subtlety of the discussion, but they all seem to be thoroughly enjoying the opportunity to get together and kibbitz.
On Wednesday morning, Manuel comes by at 6:00 a.m. to escort me to the next community. It's about an hour and a half hike through back trails to the place I'll call Laguna Toronja. The folks in Venecia had radioed ahead the night before to say I'd be coming, so community members had delayed their departure for the fields and were waiting when I got there. A few more blasts on a cow's horn and soon the whole community of about 40 adults and some of the kids assembled under a thatched roof. This time the women are included, the first time in the four community visits of this trip. It's a good thing Manuel has come along, since nobody seems to speak any Spanish here and he patiently interprets. I decide to go out on a limb, taking the opportunity to ask the women about their participation in decision-making. When the question is translated, the women giggle and cover their mouths and avert their gaze, and the men start to answer for them. I repeat the question, saying I'd really like to hear what the women have to say. It's sort of walking a fine line, since it's not the place of a visitor passing through to try to change the dynamics and traditions of a community, but they had after all included the women in this meeting.
After a bit more embarrassed giggling, a middle-aged woman stands up and begins to talk. She launches into a long monologue which the interpreter has to interrupt from time to time so I can keep up. It wasn't exactly what I had in mind with the question, but it is a fascinating outpouring of her life story. She recalls how when she was small, her father who worked for the rich finquero tried to gain a little freedom by building a little thatch house at the edge of the forest outside the finca, and the enraged finquero had him beaten up and burned down his house. They fled to a remote corner of the jungle in the Montes Azules Biosphere Reserve, where the public security forces later invaded and drove them out again. After drifting around and working on borrowed land, they took the opportunity after the rebellion to settle here on recovered land in 2003. "It's not the same anymore as when the rich people used to tell us what we had to do," she says with pride, "Now we have land, now we eat in peace, you can do what you want. It's not like what I went through before."
At the end of the assembly, the women bring generous portions of beans and scrambled eggs for me and Manuel, then two boys are assigned to escort me down to the road about 45 minutes away to wait for a truck back to town. They don't speak a word of Spanish, and in any case they are focused on trying to nab a squirrel with their slingshots on the way to bring back some dinner. After a couple of hours at the roadside a truck comes by, and by evening I'm back in San Cristóbal.
Time in town is always a scramble to finish up urban tasks before heading out again. Bernard, the French sociology doctoral student who studies autonomous education in the jungle, is in town, so we hang out and catch up. Also some of the members of the Mexico City collective of teacher trainers, who are now focusing on their fair trade coffee and agroecology training projects, have sent one of their collaborators whom I'll call Valeria to crash at my house. She was just out in El Conejo for some meetings with the autonomous municipal council about the agroecology project they're just starting, and she stopped in San Cristóbal for an admissions interview at the anthropology institute CIESAS where she's applying to the Master's program. She wants to do a Master's thesis comparing indigenous autonomy in a Zapatista community in the northern zone of Chiapas with another indigenous community, perhaps in Oaxaca.
Valeria's project sounds great and the interview apparently went well, and Bernard and I were happy to be able to give some encouragement to a progressive young academic who wants to do research in Zapatista communities. There's only a small group of such people, and in fact Bernard and Mariana and I have started pulling the group together to see if we can produce an edited volume that would give a picture of life in the autonomous communities. The people we've contacted so far have responded enthusiastically, and we're trying to move quickly to get some of this material into circulation; in part as a counterpoint to the armchair academics in Mexico City who are writing about Chiapas with a jaded if not hostile outlook on zapatismo. In a recent newspaper article Marcos expressed frustration with academics who claim not to take a political stand, and a group of pro-Zapatista academics organized a panel at the University of Guadalajara (coinciding with the Other Campaign's stop there) to try to create some momentum for politically committed scholarship.
While Valeria was in town we also took a quick trip up to the highlands Caracol of Oventic, to see if we could meet with representatives of a fair trade coffee collective there to learn some tips of the business that might be applied to the project that the teacher trainers are trying to get off the ground in the jungle region. Unfortunately the leaders of the coffee coop were not there, but we did get a lead on how we might track some of them down in San Cristóbal.
Bruno invited me to join him for an interview he has scheduled at 7:00 a.m. Wednesday in Ocosingo with Pedro Chulín, the swaggering leader of OPDDIC (the new rural indigenous organization that most consider to be a paramilitary group, but that its leaders insist is just a sort of social action committee). It promises to be an interesting conversation.
